Grading The Performance: Minnesota


Devin Gardner was an All-American QB coming out of HS. Even so, his skills and ability at the QB position has largely been an unknown. Gardner beat out Tate Forcier for the #2 QB job during the fall of 2010 and briefly played in relief action but few outside of the coaches had seen him in extended action before Saturday.

The passing game was shaky early as Devin attempted to shake off the rust associated with not playing meaAnnArbor.comningful snaps at QB for months. Everything about Devin’s 1st quarter interception was bad, footwork, mechanics, and decision making. Once he settled down, Devin really began to dial things in. There were still several ill-advised throws and decisions but for the most part Devin looked like the QB many expected coming out of the high school. Devin adds an element the Michigan offense that fans haven’t seen in quite awhile. Downfield passing has been a major strength in Devin’s game since high. There may be poor decisions and throws but Devin throws one beautiful deep ball.

For the most part Michigan shied away from using Devin on designed runs. With only 2 healthy QBs the risk was just too high to exploit Devin’s true duel-threat ability. Devin did show great anticipation and reaction to pressure and was quick to move out of the pocket and scramble when the plays called for it. Unlike Denard who seems averse to scrambling, Devin was decisive when it came to when to take off and when to wait things out in the pocket.

Grade: A-

Running Back

The running backs continue to be handcuffed by the play of the offensive line. Both Fitzgerald Toussaint and Thomas Rawls ran hard but there were limited opportunities to produce big numbers on the ground. Rawls was especially successful in short yardage and is proving to be quite the load for opposing teams on handle. Rawls breaks a lot of tackles and for the most part he has to because of the issues the team has up front. Fitz also ran hard and was finally able to break through late in the game on a long TD run. It seems as though it has been a year since Fitz busted a major run of significance so Saturday’s run was big even if the game was already decided.

Grade: B+

Wide Receivers/TEs

No unit was happier with the decision to start Devin more than the WRs. Devin’s game opens up things for the WRs and allows them into part of the route tree that Michigan seldom uses with Denard at QB. Jeremy Gallon had a nice bounce back game after really struggling against Nebraska. For a guy his size Gallon has knack for making plays on the ball in the air and Michigan doesn’t hesitate to throw him jump balls in the endzone. Drew Dileo had another productive day, catching 4 passes for 69yds and the game’s first TD. Even Roy Roundtree got into the act, making a circus catch between two defenders to setup a 2nd half Michigan TD.

The one disappointment has been the disappearance of Devin Funchess in the passing game. Michigan tried getting Funchess involved on the goal line several times but were unsuccessful and he finished the game with just 1 catch for 7 yards.

Grade: B+

Offensive Line

The offensive line is regressing, there’s just no other way to put it. The line has struggled to run block all season but now the guys up front are having issues in pass protection as well. Through the season, pass protection has consistently been the one area where the line has done a very good job. That ended on Saturday as the line found themselves flat footed and overpowered at times throughout the game. The interior of the offensive line played especially poorly and had all kinds of issues in both run blocking and pass protection. The lack of push from the guards and center is nothing new but watch defenders run through or around the interior of the Michigan line was disconcerting at best.

Grade: D

Defensive Line

After weeks of solid play, the defensive line finally caved and got themselves pushed around. Minnesota was able to grind out chunks of yardage on the ground and if not for the score getting out of hand, the Gophers would have likely posted a big rushing tally. Unlike the last 5 games when the big guys up front were able to hold the point of attack and at the very least reroute the man across from them, the defensive line was pushed back or sealed off throughout the game. Quinton Washington and Will Campbell had previously been able to occupy offensive linemen and shed blocks in pursuit, that rarely happened on Saturday and Michigan paid the price from a numbers standpoint.

Michigan continues to get very little in the way of pressure on the QB from the front 4, outside of the times when Jake Ryan slides down and puts his hand on the ground. The defensive ends had been making up for the lack of sacks with pressures and holding the edge in the run game but ends had some trouble with that in this game. The defensive line accounted for zero sacks and only 1 TFL on the day which is not something that is sustainable if Michigan wants to produce good defensive play.

After Grade: C-


Kenny Demens and Jake Ryan led the way again from a tackles standpoint, with Demens making it into the double digits. Issues up front led to the LBers having to fight off more blocks than they have in the past and there were issues with leverage and taking good angles to the ball carrier. As a whole, the LBers played cleanup more than anything else which is out of character for them based on what has been happening the rest of the season.

Grade: B


Michigan is ranked very highly in pass defense but the numbers are misleading to a degree. From a statistical standpoint the secondary has held opposing teams to very low numbers. The actual play on the field tells a different story. Michigan has been fortunate in not playing a lot of teams with productive passing games as the cover guys have had their share of issues of late. More accurate throws would have resulted in a number of big plays on Saturday and Michigan was lucky to avoid giving up a ton of yards. On several occasions the J.T Floyd and Raymon Taylor were beaten and simply interfered with the opposing WR to prevent a big play. At one point Michigan was called for back to back pass interference on plays where the cover man was beaten badly or lost in space. Jordan Kovacs did come up with a big TFL that stalled a Minnesota drive.

Grade: D

Special Teams

Will Hagerup has been punting so well this season he was due for a stinker. That stinker came on Saturday as Hagerup averaged just 29.3yds per punt and had two shanks in the game that gave Minnesota great field position.

Dennis Norfleet continues to run hard and make guys miss on kick returns but big plays continues to be elusive for the diminutive back. There are times when Norfleet probably should just take a knee in the end zone but with his speed and quickness he always feels like there is a play to be made. It is difficult to really judge Norfleet harshly on plays when he probably shouldn’t come out of the end zone because of his big play potential and the fact that he has often made sometime out of the nothing.

The kick coverage unit unfortunately struggled to contain Minnesota on kickoffs. The Gophers busted off a 45yd return early in the game and continued to get good returns, averaging 25yds per kick return.

Grade: C-

A: Unit played as close to flawless as possible. Unit played well enough to win the game on their own.

B: Unit had a major positive impact on the game but also had several assignment/execution miscues.

C: Unit did not negatively or positively affect the game. Unit made key positive plays along with several errors.

D: Unit made multiple critical errors that could potentially cost the team a win. Unit blew assignments and had poor execution across the board.

F: Play of the unit was bad enough that it could directly cost the team a victory.

Note: Plus and minuses denote degrees of the grade.